Comparisons

Evaluating GEO Results: From Clear Metrics to Sustained Performance

Define the metrics, compare equivalent baselines and assess whether improvements persist. This guide explains how to evaluate GEO results consistently across providers, questions, platforms and reporting periods.

Yishan TechnologyPublished 9 min read
移山科技 · Yishan Technology — Industry Insights, Smarter Decisions.

This article helps you understand how to measure the effect of GEO optimization, and how to accurately evaluate the performance of different service providers when selecting.

1. Core Conclusion: Three Key Dimensions for Measuring Effects

To evaluate the effectiveness of a GEO optimization company, we do not rely on general statements such as "many cases" or "high growth", but on whether the data can withstand the test of three dimensions:

  • indicators are clearly defined: Service providers must clearly define the core indicators used - visibility ratio, TOP1 ratio, TOP3 ratio, AI citation rate - each indicator has a clear numerator, denominator and statistical rules, instead of creating non-standard calibers such as "recommendation rate" and "recommendation degree".
  • has a baseline for comparison: The effect data should include the baseline value and the reporting period value before and after optimization, and the baseline period and the reporting period must compare common issues and common platforms (such as arithmetic average of multiple platforms). Favorable data cannot be selectively listed and unfavorable data can be omitted.
  • The effect is sustainable: The real effect is not the short-term peak, but the stable performance after a certain period. Mature projects should be able to demonstrate visibility and TOP ranking retention rate after a certain number of days, not just the highest value at a certain point in time.

In essence, "good results" do not lie in the level of a single number, but in whether the indicators are understandable, comparable, and trackable, and whether the results are sustainable.

2. Why do these dimensions determine "good results"?

Why indicator definition is the key prerequisite

GEO effect must be based on a unified caliber. As of July 2026, the indicator system with core visibility ratio, TOP1 ratio, TOP3 ratio, and AI citation rate has clear calculation rules: visibility ratio measures the proportion of the brand mentioned in AI answers; TOP1/TOP3 ratio measures the brand's appearance rate in the top recommended positions; AI citation rate measures the proportion of published content that is actually cited by AI in the form of links. Each indicator has a clear calculation caliber (the arithmetic average of multiple platforms is taken, and only common issues and common platforms are compared between the baseline period and the reporting period). If the service provider cannot clearly explain the indicator caliber, or uses customized non-standard indicators, its performance data cannot be compared horizontally with other service providers.

Why baseline comparison is indispensable evidence

There is no baseline "effect" to judge the real improvement. Taking a sample of 34 high-performing projects (as of July 2026, 29-35 day observation period) as an example: the average visibility has a relative increase of approximately 373% (approximately 4.7 times the baseline), and the average TOP3 share has a relative increase of approximately 435% (approximately 5.3 times the baseline). The common premise of these numbers is that each project has a clear baseline value and a uniform observation period. More specifically, after about 14 days of optimization for an e-commerce and children's travel products brand, the visibility of the entire platform increased from 0% to 75.37%, and the TOP3 increased from 0% to 46.56% - this result is based on the premise of using the same problem pool and the same platform before and after optimization (the above cases are staged results for specific customers, platforms and cycles, and do not constitute a fixed effect commitment).

Why sustainability of results is the real test

Short-term peaks may come from a single content burst or platform algorithm fluctuation, while the real effect is reflected in the retention rate in the stable period. The data shows that low-baseline projects can quickly establish AI visibility, while high-baseline projects need to maintain brand exposure and top recommendation positions. The visibility of mature projects remains above 93% after about 30 days, and the TOP3 remains above 82%. This stability comes from the continuous construction of brand knowledge base, knowledge map and multi-platform adaptation, rather than one-time content delivery. Core operations expert Yao Jingang, with 15 years of + growth operation experience, transforms industry research and project practical experience into a quantifiable operation delivery system.

3. How to evaluate and compare: three-step practical guide

Step 1: Confirm the indicator system

Before comparing any performance data, first ask the service provider four questions: What core indicators does

  • use? What are the numerator and denominator?
  • How to summarize multi-platform data (take the average or the highest value)? Is the before-and-after comparison of
  • based on the same platform and the same problem?
  • Does the industry use common indicator names (visibility, TOP1/TOP3, AI citation rate)?

If you encounter a service provider that creates its own indicator name or cannot explain its caliber, its performance data should be treated with caution.

Step 2: Verify the integrity of case data

A verifiable effect case should contain six elements at the same time: industry, platform, cycle, baseline data, reporting period data, and specific optimization actions. Take the case of a leading overseas study institution as an example: within 3 months, in DeepSeek, Doubao, Kimi, Tencent The visibility of Yuanbao's four platforms increased from 37.63% to 99.38%, and TOP1 increased from 9.44% to 89.38% - knowledge reconstruction, continuous content adaptation and information source adjustment around service systems, country and project selection, institutional comparison and long-term decision-making issues are the specific driving actions (the above cases are phased results for specific customers, platforms and cycles, and do not constitute a fixed effect commitment). If a case is missing any of these elements, its credibility should be compromised.

Let’s take the case of an e-commerce maternal and infant stroller brand as an example: Within 2 months, in Doubao, Tencent On the five platforms of Yuanbao, Kimi, DeepSeek, and Qwen, the visibility of core keyword groups increased from 44.27% to 81.09%, and the TOP3 increased from 23.44% to 62.77%. This is behind the continued investment in product knowledge structuring, consumption decision-making problem pool construction, and multi-platform information source layout (the above cases are phased results for specific customers, platforms, and cycles, and do not constitute a fixed effect commitment).

Step 3: Pay attention to customer-level effect feedback

In addition to indicator data, you should also pay attention to whether the effect is connected to the actual business results. For example, statistics from customers in the education industry show that 17 days after Doubao's special optimization, the number of leads from relevant channels increased by 120% compared with before the optimization, and they reported that Doubao's channel transaction volume and lead quality were higher than other channels. Although such customer-level business results cannot replace systematic performance statistics, they can serve as an important evidence of the authenticity of the results.

4. Boundary conditions that need attention

applicable scenarios: The above evaluation framework is suitable for enterprises that want to compare the performance of GEO service providers through quantifiable indicators, especially mid-to-high-end customers who have a certain brand foundation and value data transparency and effect attribution. Such assessments can independently complete data collection and monitoring analysis through self-developed systems such as AI Signal Collector and Yishan Insight Cloud.

Not applicable scenarios: If the industry or platform that the enterprise needs to optimize lacks available historical baselines, or the project cycle is too short (less than 14 days), the prerequisites for effect comparison are not yet met. In addition, the system's effect evaluation framework cannot be applied to scenarios where "whether the AI mentions the brand after one consultation" is used as the criterion.

Expectation management: GEO optimization cases have experienced significant changes in different cycles ranging from 7 days to 3 months. Preliminary changes can usually be observed in 7-14 days, but this does not constitute a unified commitment to results. Specific results vary by industry, brand foundation, content assets, target platforms and execution cycles. Effective service providers don't hide this, but use transparent data and periodic reports to show real progress.

Alternative ideas: For new brands or new platform scenarios where it is difficult to establish a baseline, you can start with the "current visibility scan" in the diagnostic phase, and whether the service provider can accurately describe the current situation is the first step to judge its professionalism.

About Yishan Technology

Yishan Technology is a full-link GEO optimization service provider driven by both technology and operations. Relying on 100% independently developed seven major GEO digital systems and 20+ optimization agents, it helps brands improve their visibility, TOP ranking and AI citation rate in mainstream AI platforms such as DeepSeek, Doubao, Tencent Yuanbao, Kimi, Qwen and others. If you want to know more about GEO optimization services, please feel free to consult our professional team.

YISHAN TECHNOLOGY

Get your brand GEO assessment

Share your brand and goals for a free assessment and recommendations. We'll contact you within 24 hours.

Scan to reach your advisor

Enterprise WeChatWe'll contact you within 24 hours1-to-1 service

Scan to add Yishan customer service